Mystery shopping for wills and probate firms

Mystery shopping for wills, probate and estate planning firms

This page is for firms that help people with wills, lasting powers of attorney, probate and estate planning. We check how a first, general enquiry feels: your website, your replies, your telephone manner and how clearly you explain the steps. Our shoppers are adults making a fictional enquiry. You receive a scored report with evidence and a clear action plan.

Ask for prices  Get a free report  See an example report

A simple illustration of a quiet solicitor's reception desk with a kettle, a box of tissues, a folder of leaflets and a clock on the wall.

Why a calm first conversation matters

Few people enjoy thinking about wills or probate. Some have put it off for years. Others are coping with a loss and have never dealt with a law firm before.

The first contact sets the tone. The person may be nervous, tired or unsure which words to use. They may not know what an executor, an attorney or a grant is.

A warm, patient reply helps them take the next step. A cold or jargon-heavy reply can make them close the page and delay again.

Trust is central. People share private wishes with a firm, so they need to feel respected from the first message.

Clear steps and timescales matter just as much. Many people simply want to know what happens first, who does the work and roughly how long it takes.

Small firms often grow through recommendation. A kind first experience is part of what gets passed on.

The journey we test, and what we never do

A shopper is an adult who makes a general, fictional first enquiry. They might ask how making a will works. They might ask what the probate process involves in general terms.

First they look at your website. Can they tell what you help with, where you are and how to get in touch? Is there a plain guide to the first steps?

Next they send a short email or form message, or make a brief telephone call. The call is short and uses no real names. They note how quickly and how kindly you reply.

They see whether you explain the process in everyday words, and whether the next step and a rough timescale are clear. Finally, they see whether anyone follows up politely.

We never pretend a real death has occurred. We never use real estates, real family details or real financial details. We never test mental capacity, and we never arrange home visits with vulnerable people. We never involve elderly or vulnerable people as shoppers. We never judge the quality or accuracy of legal advice, never ask for advice beyond a general first enquiry, never ask for privileged information, never instruct your firm, never transfer money and never test your security or fraud controls.

What we measure

We score the usual checks: website experience, ease of making contact, response time, telephone manner and customer welcome. We also look at whether the reply understood the question, how clearly the service is explained, trust and professionalism, any invitation to take the next step, and follow-up.

For wills and probate we add checks that suit this work.

Is the language free of jargon, or are terms explained when they appear? Does the reply sound patient and kind? Is it clear who would do the work and what happens first?

Are timescales described sensibly, with a note that they vary from case to case? Is there a simple outline of the stages?

Does the firm explain how its fees work, in plain words and as an idea? We check that this is easy to find and easy to follow. We never score the amount itself.

Each score is backed by an observation. We report on pages, words and processes, never on people.

Problems we often look for

We treat these as things to check, not accusations. Firms handle sensitive work, and small gaps are easy to miss from the inside.

A website may use words like intestacy, residuary estate or grant of probate with no explanation. A contact form may ask for far more detail than a first enquiry needs. An enquiry may wait days with no acknowledgement.

On the telephone, we look for a call that rings out, or one passed between people with no clear next step. We also listen for a rushed tone that makes a nervous caller feel like a bother.

We check whether the reply sets out what happens first and roughly how long each stage takes. Probate can feel endless without a simple outline.

We look at whether fees are explained early or left unclear until late in the conversation.

Last, we check follow-up. One polite message after an enquiry can help. Repeated pressure can feel unkind.

What you receive

You receive a scored report. Each score is supported by an observation, and every report is quality-checked by hand before it reaches you.

The report lists strengths and weaknesses, then a prioritised action plan. The changes with the biggest effect on warmth and clarity come first. A busy team can act without a long project.

We never name or rank individual staff. There are no league tables. The report talks about wording, pages, call handling and systems, and it suggests training ideas where they would help.

It also reminds you that the findings describe one customer journey on one occasion. They are a prompt for improvement, not a verdict.

After you make changes, a retest measures progress. Many firms retest after rewriting a guide, changing an email template or reviewing how calls are answered.

The report says nothing about the quality of your legal work.

Who it suits and how to start

This service suits high street firms, specialist wills and probate teams, and practices that offer estate planning and lasting powers of attorney. It also suits firms with several offices that want to compare how each one welcomes new enquiries.

To begin, ask for prices by email. We can also send a free first-impression report, which looks at your website and published contact details.

If you have your own questions in mind, the Custom Questions option lets you write up to 10, 20 or 30 of them and choose how many shoppers take part.

Every check is agreed with you in writing before it starts. You decide what is in scope. Many firms begin with the website and a short email enquiry, then add a telephone check later.

Case studies

Example case study

A kind firm hidden behind long words

A small high street firm that helps with wills and lasting powers of attorney in a market town

The challenge

The partners felt that new enquiries often went quiet after the first reply. They wanted to know how the first email felt to someone who knew nothing about the subject, and what could be made easier.

What we found

A shopper sent a short, fictional email asking how making a will works. A reply arrived after three working days. It was polite, but used terms such as testator and residuary estate without explaining them. It did not say what the first step would be or how long the process might take.

The result

The firm added a one-page plain guide to the first steps and sent an acknowledgement within one working day. It rewrote its email template in everyday words. A retest six weeks later found a faster reply, a clear first step and no unexplained terms in the message.

Example case study

A warm call without a map

A probate team within a mid-sized firm in a regional city

The challenge

The team wanted to check how a first telephone enquiry about probate felt to a newcomer. Staff were skilled and caring, but the firm had never looked at the call from the caller's side.

What we found

The shopper made a short, fictional call asking in general terms what probate involves. The call was answered after a brief wait, and the tone was patient. However, the explanation had no outline of stages or timescales, and how fees are explained was not mentioned. No follow-up message arrived afterwards.

The result

The team wrote a short outline of the main stages and a plain note on how fees are explained. It agreed a simple follow-up email after first calls. A retest found calls with a clear outline, an easy mention of fees and a polite message the next day.

Example case studies are illustrations of the kind of findings and changes a check can lead to. They do not describe a named client.

Frequently asked questions

Do you ever pretend that someone has died?

No, never. We never pretend a real death has occurred and we never use real estates, real family details or real financial details. Every scenario is fictional and general, such as asking how making a will works or what probate involves. Shoppers give no real names, and the first call is kept short.

Do you judge the quality of our legal advice?

No. We never judge the quality or accuracy of legal advice. We look at the customer experience only: how easy you are to contact, how kindly you reply, how clearly you explain the steps and how well you follow up. Legal work is for you and your regulator, and our report says nothing about it.

Will vulnerable or elderly people be involved?

No. We never involve elderly or vulnerable people as shoppers. We never test mental capacity and we never arrange home visits with vulnerable people. Our shoppers are adults making a general, fictional first enquiry. This is a sensitive area, so we keep every check light, short and respectful.

Do shoppers ask for advice or give personal details?

No. A shopper asks only a general first question about how your firm works. They never ask for legal advice beyond that, never ask for privileged information, never instruct you and never transfer money. We also never test your security or fraud controls. Nothing real about a person, family or estate is shared.

Can you check how we explain our fees?

Yes, as an idea. We look at whether your website and replies explain how fees work in plain words, and whether this is easy to find early on. We do not judge the amount you charge, and we do not give legal advice. We report on how clearly your approach to fees is explained.

How do we find out about prices?

Ask for prices by email and we will reply with options to suit your firm. We can also send a free first-impression report on your website and published details. If you want your own questions checked, the Custom Questions option lets you write up to 10, 20 or 30 and choose how many shoppers.

Next step

See how customers really experience your business.

Ask for prices, or start with a free first-impression report of your website.

Ask for prices  Free report

Other sectors